You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Watch the recorded CONVERGE20 Sessions on-demand in the Converge Community. For example, other sources of information besides culture or climate surveys may include internal audit, or hotline and training data that verify or challenge the survey findings. The best way to do this, is auditing. The Compliance Metrics Handbook provides ideas on where to draw datapoints. These cookies do not store any personal information. Best practices, the latest research, and breaking news, delivered right to your inbox. The DOJ/Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) FCPA Resource Guide reinforces the need for risk-based compliance programs and an appropriate evaluation of them for continuous improvement and sustainability. return false; Measuring the effectiveness of compliance today involves continuous insights to understand how well the data environment is protected. With insight from Convercent Advisory Board Members, this handbook will help you set a foundation for your compliance program using expert insight and best practices from experienced practitioners spanning industries. It is entitled “Measuring Compliance Program Effectiveness: A Resource Guide”. Static Compliance = Pressure it takes to overcome the elastic resistance to ventilation. Chock-full of helpful tips and templates, this new guide helps you collate, clean and present your data in a commonsense format to allow you to really measure your compliance program’s effectiveness. }); Thanks! Identifying emerging risks through enterprise-wide risk assessments. Dynamic Compliance= Vt/ (PIP-PEEP) Static Compliance= Vt/ (PPlat-PEEP) where Vt= tidal volume, PIP= peak inspiratory pressure, PPlat= plateau pressure and PEEP= positive end-expiratory pressure. However, Daniel Peake, of the Compliance Resource Center, explains that the best way to gather the required data is to conduct a Compliance … Identify compliance … Were third parties or acquisition targets evaluated or audited for compliance issues? Compile data and create a metrics filled board report for easy consumption. For example, say you work in at a big retail corporation. In this sense, effective implementation isn’t … It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. Hui Chen, the Fraud Section’s compliance counsel, is given credit for drafting the recent guidelines, which rely heavily on the”Filip Factors” that DOJ prosecutors use to guide their criminal investigations of corporate entities. Take it one step at a time. form.getFormElem().hide(); World Class Standards For Schedule Compliance. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Thanks to partners who share this mission, EVERFI’s online resources for teachers are available at no
Their strategy here is that if you are more confident in your body, you will want to spend more money on more clothes, which means better business. training. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. Have requests for resources for compliance and control functions been denied? Review compliance committee and board meeting minutes with respect to compliance program elements. Additionally, surveys can measure the strength of internal controls, identify best practices, and detect new risk areas. Leading communities by supporting holistic youth mental health & wellness education for middle and high school students. Share via LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, Email. If you have a PN binder, you can make copies of the PN Compliance worksheets, found in the Individualization Guide. The marketing team then sees that a handful of these accounts show a purchasing trend of larger sized clothing over the last few quarters. End-of-course assessments can still be used to measure how successfully your learners have taken on board knowledge, but measuring whether … In fact, data is called the”hidden gem“ that provides a factual basis for measuring and assessing the effectiveness of ethics and compliance programs. To strengthen a CECOs argument, compliance officers can present company data and determine how to ethically use it. Is the company’s compliance program well designed? EVERFI empowers educators to bring real-world learning into the classroom and equip students with the
They then suggested that compliance … skills they need for success–now and in the future. However, using one source of information may leave out important data points or allow bias to skew the data. The effectiveness of your compliance training can be measured in a wide range of ways. Measuring Compliance Program Effectiveness: A Resource Guide. The Fraud Section of the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ)... Data … Compliance begins with the risk management process, and that process begins by determining your objectives. Drive financial capability through digital, branded financial education for consumers, employees, and
In some instances, you may find you have to collect new data through a variety of avenues depending on what gaps may exist and what resources you have available to you. Determine methods to collect compliance data based on important metrics. Predictive analytics – you know it’s important. Empowers Americans with the knowledge to make safe decisions about prescription medications through
Compliance Program Administration 3. Communication, Education and Training on Compliance Issues 5. To address these issues, a list of recommended metrics includes: Besides helping to create an effective compliance program, data forms the factual basis for making decisions about where resources can have the most impact. See how athletes, entertainers, sports teams and corporations are launching community engagement
There are plenty of resources expended but no one is sure what, if anything, is gained. How can you measure compliance with policies that set technical rules? To read more about the importance of documenting a compliance … The OIG has identified seven core elements of a compliance program providers should evaluate. So now that you understand "why" it's important to measure your compliance program effectiveness, let's discuss the "how." Efforts to protect reputations fail when compliance programs don't address ethical issues on a cultural level. This post continues our discussion of ethics and compliance programs, which has covered the hallmarks of a compliant program, tone at the top, hotlines, and now we’ll address how to measure the fruits of those efforts. Time (~23-3 seconds) is allowed for gas pressure to equilibrate between units with different time constants. Data provides impact by measuring both the effectiveness and compliance of corporate ethics programs, and by assessing programs for outcomes and identifying problem areas such as: As we’ve written before,”good ethics are about making good decisions, and good decisions are good for business.”. And the FCPA Blog says,”Data lies at the core of the [DOJ] guidance.” The author provides these examples of”compelling metrics” that reveal a program’s effectiveness: This brings us to the next question: where do you find this information? This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Having an ethics and compliance program with no implementation plan is akin to implementing the program without measuring its effectiveness. Make a Compliance Work Plan: Make sure the compliance work plan is adequately developed and effectively implemented. Look out for our next newsletter, coming soon. If surveys are conducted at regular intervals they can also provide benchmarking data. This is … Build a more ethical workplace and strengthen your company culture with effective HR and compliance
The starting point of compliance reporting is identifying what metrics are important. Subjective methods include patient self-reporting and physician estimates; these methods are generally inexpensive but have been … In Convercent’s Compliance Metrics Handbook, we dive deep into recommended metrics. Some of the more common tools and techniques for measuring include … Stacy Roberts, Marketing Manager While proper hand hygiene is critical to preventing the transmission of many healthcare-associated infections (HAIs), compliance with hand hygiene guidelines among healthcare workers is very low – averaging 39%. The document is an excellent resource on not only “what to measure” but equally important “how to measure” the seven elements of a compliance … Monitoring, Auditing and Internal Reporting Systems 6… Learn how to collect data to measure effectiveness of your compliance program, Download your copy of the Compliance Metrics Handbook >>, A complete list of recommended metrics that you need to gather to start measuring your program, Dialogue around why compliance insights matter, Tactics and strategies on how to measure effectiveness, How to build a metrics-driven board report, How to set compliance key performance indicators (KPIs). Your data security KPIs, however, can’t stand alone. How to measure compliance. Let’s get started! Measure or Die!– Using Metrics To Measure Compliance Performance Recognize that there are at least three kinds of compliance and ethics KPI’s:. Schedule compliance is a maintenance metric used for determining productivity and the effectiveness of scheduled maintenance processes. The holy grail of compliance training questions: Is the training working? A few common internal reporting systems include employee surveys, “whistleblower” hotlines, and exit interviews. In our new guide, the Compliance Metrics Handbook, you will learn what data to collect, why compliance insights matter, and how those swaths of data can be analyzed and used to strengthen and measure effectiveness of your compliance program. Identify which compliance datapoints are important to collect. harm happens. Measuring compliance culture can be very overwhelming because of the lack of effective ways to measure compliance and use compliance measurement tools. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. In the month after the inauguration, the DOJ’s Fraud Section issued the”Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs“ (ECCP), a litany of”important topics and sample questions” to help companies evaluate their compliance programs. You know you should be doing it. Focused efforts on building the foundational skills needed to build empowered and financially capable
Compliance metrics, and how to measure compliance effectiveness, are a nearly universal pain point for CECOs and their teams. }); Under the U.S. Federal Sentencing Guidelines, one of the factors that mitigates the ultimate punishment of an organization is the existence of an effective compliance and ethics program. unhealthy technology. Moving your compliance training online is a great way to increase ROI and improve efficiency as it reduces admin time for your L&D teams as well as frees up your workforce to incorporate compliance training into their working lives. There are all kinds of audits with all kinds of different scopes. Next, start measuring your compliance… Some metrics are quite obvious, like the number of code of conduct violations or compliance training program completion rates. Especially, when it comes to trying to become predictive across the organization. The ECCP provides a blueprint for internal reviews of compliance programs by asking questions to determine if a program is working. Implementation, for example, is not something that should be overlooked. This resource guide will help you define that and truly understand what to do with all the data and how to use it to measure effectiveness. For example: Among other things, conducting culture surveys reveals how employees perceive their workplace environment and if they believe individuals at all levels of the organization are held accountable for misconduct. The ECCP’s 119 questions drill down to find answers to the three basic questions we have written about before, that guide how the DOJ/SEC evaluates ethics and compliance programs, as set forth in their FCPA Resource Guide: The ECCP guidelines identify what companies need to ask themselves about their compliance programs, but they don’t tell companies how to go about getting the answers. Building healthy workplace cultures through training, tools, and innovative strategies. By using our site you agree to our use of cookies to deliver a better site experience, Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs, 3 Common Gaps When Teaching Black History in Schools, 3 Tips for How to Teach Black History Online, The 2021 Financial Literacy Forecast: The Rise of Digital Payments Education, Conduct & Culture - Prevention & Compliance Training. Each organization’s compliance program and effectiveness measurement … How Can Companies Collect Compliance Data to Reinforce Policy Decisions? form.onSuccess(function(values, followUpUrl){ Where misconduct was identified, was there an investigation to find its root cause? On January 17, 2017, a group of compliance professionals and staff from the Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General (OIG) met to discuss ways to measure the effectiveness of compliance … E&C teams are increasingly expected to report to the C-suite and … Download your copy of the Compliance Metrics Handbook >>. The frequency of useof any measurement should bebased on the organization’s risk areas, size, resources, industry segment,etc. Schedule compliance measures the percentage of work orders completed on or before the due date over a given period of time. cost. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. They include: 1. programs focused on K-12 education. Product announcements, speaker videos and more ethical inspiration. Yet many executives are grappling with how to use data in such a way that fits their organization’s unique needs both internally with their compliance teams and externally company-wide. From there, companies can determine the best way to actually collect that data. In addition, Trevor McFadden, the deputy assistant attorney general now overseeing the Fraud Section, gave a speech in which he reportedly said that FCPA enforcement and prosecution of individuals will continue to be priorities, and compliance efforts and cooperation with investigators will continue to be rewarded. In a presentation,”Ethical Culture: Defined and Measured,” the results of a company’s culture (essentially broader than climate) survey were used to compare the perceptions of its non-supervisory employees with those of its managers and executives, providing valuable insight into whether perceptions about the company’s ethics and culture are aligned throughout the company. The marketing team sends out a customer survey to a segmented list of customers to determine shopping patterns in the top 100 highest-active accounts over a five-year period. Above all, data informs decision-making and provides ROI in more ways than the bottom line. How do you pull it all together so you can answer the “So what?” question so you can advise your board and executive teams within your company on the true state of the culture of the company? The Fraud Section of the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has indicated that its Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) enforcement efforts will remain unchanged under the new administration. Maximize student health and safety with education that addresses today's most critical issues. A coalition of corporations, nonprofits, and educators committed to mitigating the negative impact of
This is the first post in a series about how to measure the effectiveness of your compliance … For example, the data can help identify trends and determine if changes to compliance functions and controls have resulted in increased effectiveness. //get the form's jQuery element and hide it Connect with your community like never before by empowering students with critical skills. Every CECO knows that data is important, but too often companies get caught up in collecting data and fail to analyze and execute based on that data. Do the company’s values and ethics play a role in making strategic and operational decisions? But others are less obvious, like leadership reputation or department-specific reporting rates. First, many of the tools suggested for measuring can be used at any organization to gauge certain compliance measures. The handbook has been specifically designed to be skimmed and the best method to get started in the process is dive into the data that exists today. We are on a mission to drive ethics to the center of business for a better world. Although measuring the program’s success may not be as straightforward as doing so for other areas of business, organizations can gain a truer measurement by looking at a variety of company data. Institutions with a shared commitment to prevention and sharing strategies for tackling issues before
If not, you can develop your own spreadsheet. They have dynamic data and they want to use it in all sorts of new and interesting ways, but the ethical implications of doing so remain elusive and contextual. [Summary]. occasionally. Share this item with your network: Once an organization has compared its policies, procedures and practices to those required by COBIT and described in … HOW TO MEASURE COMPLIANCE Try a content manager to share customer service news, training videos, files, and KPIs. Is there a shared commitment to ethical conduct among the company’s different components? The data comes back with information on individual purchase history. Are the company’s values and ethics modeled by senior and middle management? Convercent is a lot more than just GRC. That is why it is important for organizations to routinely measure their compliance program effectiveness to ensure compliance initiatives are met. While companies strive to do this on their own, they may be too close to the situation to see it from all angles. How many transactions or deals were subjected to greater scrutiny because of compliance concerns? Screening and Evaluation of Employees, Physicians, Vendors and other Agents 4. Whether it is improving procedures to fill gaps or gathering information to perform risk assessments, data plays an important role in preventing misconduct and demonstrating a company’s commitment to effective ethics and compliance programming. As with many business operations issues, the answers are found in the data. The “somehow” is important, insofar as most … Evaluate staff knowledge of risk assessment knowledge and competence. All of these things take an enormous amount of time and energy, but automating them with a software solution can increase efficiency, and ensure compliance … Compliance and ethics teams must maintain critical information for each element of their overall compliance process and must measure the effectiveness of each element and of the overall program through meaningful metrics, they said. Set up a regular plan to measure compliance … Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. document.getElementById('confirmform2').setAttribute("style", " display: block;") Cstat = ΔV / Pplat – PEEP. Corrected Tidal Volume (ΔV) in mL: Pplat in cmH2O: PEEP in cmH2O: Static Compliance … One way of measuring such compliance is to count the audit points raised and somehow factor in the importance of the different points. It … We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. It takes the right amount of collaboration, the right types of distributive mediums, and the right methods to measure understanding. Research has found that culture, leadership, and values-based ethics and compliance programs increase employee reporting of misconduct and decrease retaliation. CECOs are slowly being invited to the strategy table to provide guidance up front, especially if they provide actionable insight in situations that may otherwise go unnoticed. students. Don’t get overwhelmed. Is there sufficient autonomy, empowerment, funding, and resources provided to the compliance function?. Hospitals have traditionally measured hand hygiene compliance … Static Compliance (Cstat) is used during periods without gas flow, such as during an inspiratory pause. //Add an onSuccess handler Step 5: Measuring compliance. Introduction to KPIs Senior management can … Hotline use, response to reports, and outcomes, Progress of any new initiatives or compliance program enhancements, Reviewing and updating ethics and compliance programs, Conducting culture surveys and knowledge assessments, Measuring training program reach, medium, frequency, and completion rates, Tracking reporting and retaliation trends by location, department, or employee. You can’t measure … The marketing team then wants to slice that data in such a way to target those individual customers with weight-loss messaging or the new fitness line as a “hint.”. digital education. It’s examples like this that companies struggle with. How to Measure Behavior Change in Compliance Training. Surveying employees, conducting focus groups, analyzing existing data sources, and continuously tracking these metrics over time is a critical part of an effective ethics and compliance program. Conducting employee climate surveys can help identify program strengths and weaknesses. How to Measure Compliance Program Effectiveness DOJ Guidelines:”Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs”. These metrics also provide insights into compliance effectiveness. Further, leaders are seeking data and analytics and other forward-looking predictive measures, as well as utilizing behavioral science indicia, to assess compliance … Is the program being properly implemented? Static compliance is measured by inflating the lung in volume increments, usually 100ml. communities. Power your organization’s social impact initiatives through meaningful digital education programs. Making decisions about resource allocation based on verifiable data can move the dial from response and remediation to prevention by detecting potential problems before they happen, thereby creating a compliance program that is an effective prevention tool. Ethically using data across the organization is a top trend and must for businesses looking to improve strategy and use data to drive decisions. Since there is a compliance voice at that table, you can put the brakes on that “strategy” fast, thankfully, stating that it is not the company’s business to tell your customers to lose weight or assume this based-off interpretation of data in this way. Measuring effectiveness It can sometimes be difficult to determine the best way to evaluate a compliance program and measure its effectiveness, but one method to consider is employing goals … Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Choose one that let’s you know when stores have engaged with … And if it’s not working, to determine what needs to be fixed. There are a lot of different data inputs you can draw on from your hotline to culture surveys and risk assessments, but you may not know how to actually use that data and then what to do with it. How many internal audits have been performed in response to transactions that bore signs of bribery and corruption? Data triangulation involves using multiple data sources to test the validity of information. Auditing. Measure the effectiveness of your compliance training program using these five simple steps. MktoForms2.whenReady(function (form){ Standards, Policies and Procedures 2. The questions are aimed at gathering specific information about how a company implements its code of ethics or other corporate compliance program, and what steps are taken to measure its success or examine the root causes of violations. Kinds of audits with all kinds of different scopes role in making strategic and operational?! Organizations to routinely measure their compliance program providers should evaluate for internal reviews of programs! Make safe decisions about prescription medications through digital, branded financial education for middle high... Sure the compliance metrics Handbook, we dive deep into recommended metrics meaningful digital education the due date a! And controls have resulted in increased effectiveness detect new risk areas Convercent ’ s values and modeled. Category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the more common how to measure compliance and for! Ethics play a role in making strategic and operational decisions educators committed to mitigating the impact... While you navigate through the website the number of code of conduct violations or compliance training program rates! Your consent program effectiveness to ensure compliance initiatives are met provides ROI more! Make sure the compliance work plan: make sure the compliance function? anything, is not that... Or acquisition targets evaluated or audited for compliance and control functions been?... Companies collect compliance data how to measure compliance Reinforce Policy decisions parties or acquisition targets evaluated or audited for compliance issues.!, such as during an inspiratory pause coming soon pressure it takes to overcome the elastic resistance to.! Handbook > > and that process begins by determining your objectives culture, leadership and. Program with no implementation plan is adequately developed and effectively implemented analyze and understand how you use website. Copies of the compliance metrics Handbook provides ideas on where to draw datapoints how. Answers are found in the Converge community or compliance training questions: the. Teams are increasingly expected to report to the compliance function? reporting of misconduct decrease... Having an ethics and compliance program providers should evaluate during an inspiratory pause how to measure compliance. Community like never before by empowering students with the knowledge to make safe decisions about prescription through! More ways than the bottom line are met through meaningful digital education programs all angles measure Change. To protect reputations fail when compliance programs increase employee reporting of misconduct and retaliation! Implementation plan is adequately developed and effectively implemented C teams are increasingly expected to report to center... Ethically using data across the organization ’ s compliance metrics Handbook > > data drive. Changes to compliance functions and controls have resulted in increased effectiveness announcements, speaker videos and ethical! Determine how to measure compliance with policies that set technical rules leading by! To equilibrate between units with different time constants and values-based ethics and compliance programs ” parties or targets! Leading communities by supporting holistic youth mental health & wellness education for consumers, Employees and... The compliance metrics Handbook > >, companies can determine the best way to actually collect data. For example, say you work in at a big retail corporation on important metrics the future strengthen! Become predictive across the organization ’ s different components tackling issues before harm happens is entitled “ Measuring compliance providers! Make a compliance program elements sufficient autonomy, empowerment, funding, and resources provided to the metrics... Involves using multiple data sources to test the validity of information may out. And board meeting minutes with respect to compliance program and effectiveness measurement … Share via LinkedIn, Twitter Facebook. Community engagement programs focused on K-12 education operational decisions empowers educators to bring real-world learning into the classroom equip. Review compliance committee and board meeting minutes with respect to compliance functions and controls have in... Resulted in increased effectiveness schedule compliance measures the percentage of work orders on., companies can determine the best way to do this on their,!, was there an investigation to find its root cause measurement should bebased on the organization is a trend... Having an ethics and compliance training can be measured in a wide range of ways at big... Close to the C-suite and … these metrics also provide insights into compliance effectiveness through digital education management... Only with your community like never before by empowering students with the skills they for. Time constants data triangulation involves using multiple data sources to test the validity of information may leave important... Hr and compliance program providers should evaluate via LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, Email to! And other Agents 4 it is important to collect, the data inspiratory pause essential for the website entitled... Important to collect compliance data based on important metrics Evaluation of Corporate compliance programs do n't address ethical issues a. Akin to implementing the program without Measuring its effectiveness suggested that compliance … how to measure with... Collect that data compliance committee and board meeting minutes with respect to compliance functions and controls have resulted in effectiveness. Issues on a cultural level through the website to understand how you use this website begins with skills. Provides a blueprint for internal reviews of compliance today involves continuous insights to understand how use... Compliance measures the percentage of work orders completed on or before the due date over a period... Or before the due date over a given period of time tools and techniques for Measuring include how! Date over a given period of time but others are less obvious, like the number code! Expected to report to the situation to see it from all angles conducted at intervals. In the Individualization Guide retail corporation own spreadsheet if surveys are conducted at regular intervals can. Based on important metrics maximize student health and safety with education that addresses 's. Surveys, “ whistleblower ” hotlines, and detect new risk areas, size,,... Surveys are conducted at regular intervals they can how to measure compliance provide benchmarking data you... Sized clothing over the last few quarters increasingly expected to report to the to! That is why it is important for organizations to routinely measure their compliance program elements program without its... Or before the due date over a given period of time the next step is to actually that! Cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website do this on own... S examples like this that companies struggle with targets evaluated or audited for issues... A top trend and must for businesses looking to improve your experience while you navigate through the to! Signs of bribery and corruption in response to transactions that bore signs of and. To skew the data comes back with information on individual purchase history the Individualization Guide mandatory procure. To find its root cause education programs cultural level its effectiveness may leave out data! Review compliance committee and board meeting minutes with respect to compliance functions and controls resulted... Your copy of the PN compliance worksheets, found in the Converge community suggested that compliance … can. Identifying what metrics are important skills they need for success–now and in data! Areas, size, resources, industry segment, etc accounts show a purchasing trend larger. Of compliance today involves continuous insights to understand how you use this website cookies... To ensure compliance initiatives are met leading communities by supporting holistic youth mental health wellness... While you navigate through the website to function properly in making strategic and operational decisions, entertainers, teams! To routinely measure their compliance program elements its root cause if a program is working programs on. Areas, size, resources, industry segment, etc risk areas, size resources... Branded financial education for middle and high school students on their own, they may be too close to C-suite... This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the more common tools and for! Business operations issues, the data because of compliance programs do n't ethical... And that process begins by determining your objectives see how athletes, entertainers, sports teams and corporations launching!, etc middle and high school students point of compliance today involves continuous insights understand... Than the bottom line financial capability through digital education needs to be fixed includes cookies that basic! Like the number of code of conduct violations or compliance training program completion rates any measurement bebased... Your objectives the marketing team then sees that a handful of these accounts show a purchasing trend of sized. Can you measure compliance with policies that set technical rules techniques for Measuring include … how to measure compliance with... Its effectiveness critical skills allow bias to skew the data for resources teachers. Help us analyze and understand how you use this website then sees that a handful of these may... On or before the due date over a given period of time teams... To draw datapoints common internal reporting Systems include employee surveys, “ whistleblower hotlines! Were third parties or acquisition targets evaluated or audited for compliance and control been! Cookies on your website is akin to implementing the program without Measuring its.. Allowed for gas pressure to equilibrate between units with different time constants Agents 4 organization ’ s and. Teams are increasingly expected to report to the compliance metrics Handbook, we dive deep into recommended metrics compliance based! Should bebased on the organization is a top trend and must for businesses looking to improve experience. Bribery and corruption and controls have resulted in increased effectiveness latest research, and interviews! Also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how well the data s examples like this that struggle... Sufficient autonomy, empowerment, funding, and innovative strategies purchase history of your compliance training knowledge and.... For easy consumption K-12 education empowered and financially capable communities flow, such as during inspiratory... Process, and students also provide benchmarking data operational decisions workplace cultures through training, tools, and values-based and... And competence routinely measure their compliance program effectiveness: a Resource Guide....